Best Thanksgiving Pies in Nassau County (2026): 8 Local Bakeries & Farm Stands Worth Visiting

There's always room for pie on Thanksgiving. Even after the turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, and second helping of gravy, somebody inevitably asks the question: "Who wants dessert?" And on Long Island, there's no shortage of places to find a good one. Nassau County has everything from historic farm stands baking traditional fruit pies to neighborhood bakeries making pumpkin, pecan, apple crumb, and elaborate French-style tarts. Some offer complete Thanksgiving preorder menus, while others have year-round favorites worth bringing to a holiday gathering. For Thanksgiving 2026, Youngs Farm in Old Brookville and Polka Dot Pound Cake in Rockville Centre are particularly useful starting points because they've published detailed holiday or seasonal pie selections. Jericho Cider Mill, Buttercooky Bakery, The French Workshop, and other established Nassau bakeries are also worth considering. Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26, 2026. Here's where to shop, what to look for, and what you need to know before ordering.

1. 1

   Youngs Farm — Old Brookville

   Best for traditional pies and a few flavors you won't find everywhere. Youngs Farm is the kind of place that makes buying dessert feel like part of the holiday tradition. Located on Hegemans Lane in Old Brookville, its farm market is known for baked goods, seasonal produce, and a country-store atmosphere. The 2026 Thanksgiving pie menu is extensive. Alongside familiar pumpkin and pecan pies, you'll find dark cherry, raspberry peach, pear crumb, tart cherry, coconut, and cranberry nut. There's even a Tollhouse pie for anyone who would rather have chocolate and nuts than another slice of pumpkin. 2026 pie prices: Pumpkin pie, 9-inch — $29.50; Pecan pie, 9-inch — $30; Dark cherry pie, 9-inch — $29.50; Pear crumb pie, 9-inch — $29.50; Apple crisp, 9-inch — $30.50; Unbaked apple pie, 9-inch — $29. Several varieties are also available in smaller sizes. If you're ordering for a large gathering, consider getting one traditional pie and another with a less common fruit filling. Pear crumb and tart cherry make an interesting change from the usual holiday selections.

   Farm stand atmosphereUnique fruit fillingsPear crumb & tart cherryPreorder pie menu

   Why go: Extensive 2026 holiday menu with classics plus rare flavors like pear crumb, raspberry peach, and Tollhouse

   91 Hegemans Lane, Old Brookville, NY 11545 (516) 626-3955 Directions

   2026 ordering: Orders open November 1; deadline is Friday, November 20 at 5 p.m. Pickup Tuesday, November 24 or Wednesday, November 25 (drive-through 7–8:15 a.m., in-store 9 a.m.–5 p.m.). Limited Manhasset café pickup also listed.

2. 2

   Jericho Cider Mill — Jericho

   Best for apple pies, crumb toppings, and classic fall flavors. Few places capture autumn on Long Island quite like Jericho Cider Mill. The business traces its roots to the early 1800s, but its pie-making story is especially interesting. According to the mill's history, the family began selling extra homemade apple pies around 1968. The first batch reportedly sold out immediately, and the recipe became part of the business. Today, pies remain central to the cider mill's appeal. The posted menu includes apple pie, apple crumb, apple-blueberry crumb, apple-raspberry crumb, apple-cranberry crumb, pumpkin, pecan, cherry, blueberry, and other fruit varieties. Pies are listed in 6-inch and 10-inch sizes, making it possible to pick up a smaller dessert or something suitable for sharing. The apple-raspberry crumb is an appealing choice for anyone who wants something different from ordinary apple pie. The pumpkin and pecan varieties cover the traditional Thanksgiving favorites. And while you're there, you can pick up fresh apple cider or cider donuts for the holiday weekend.

   Historic cider millApple crumb variationsApple-raspberry crumbCider & donuts

   Why go: Famous homemade apple pies with crispy crumb toppings, fresh-pressed cider, and fall atmosphere

   213 Route 106, Jericho, NY 11753 (516) 433-3360 Directions

   Pies offered in 6-inch and 10-inch sizes. Online storefront available; confirm 2026 Thanksgiving order deadline and pickup details directly.

3. 3

   Polka Dot Pound Cake — Rockville Centre

   Best for apple-cranberry pies and something different from the usual dessert table. Don't let the name fool you. Polka Dot Pound Cake makes more than pound cakes. This Rockville Centre bakery and café has an appealing seasonal pie menu, including several flavors that fit perfectly with Thanksgiving dinner. Its current offerings include apple crumb pie, pumpkin pie, apple-cranberry pie, and apple-cranberry crumb pie. The apple-cranberry combination is particularly well suited to Thanksgiving. The cranberries add tartness to balance the sweetness of the apples, making it a useful alternative when the rest of the meal has been especially rich. Published seasonal prices: Apple crumb pie — $28; Apple-cranberry pie — $27; Pumpkin pie — $28; Apple-cranberry crumb pie — $30; Apple cheese tart — $27. The apple cheese tart is another interesting option. It combines a shortbread crust with a lightly sweetened cheese filling, sliced apples, cinnamon sugar, and an apricot glaze. That could be a good choice if you're bringing dessert to someone else's house and want something a little different.

   Apple-cranberry crumbApple cheese tartSeasonal pie menuSouth Shore bakery

   Why go: Tart-and-sweet apple-cranberry pies and unique shortbread apple cheese tarts that stand out on any holiday table

   217 North Long Beach Road, Rockville Centre, NY 11570 (516) 544-2253 Directions

   Seasonal menu lists apple-cranberry starting Nov 1; pumpkin in Nov/Dec. Baked-to-order items may require 72 hours notice. Confirm Thanksgiving pickup directly.

4. 4

   Buttercooky Bakery & Café — Floral Park and Manhasset

   Best for a wide dessert selection when not everybody wants pie. Some Thanksgiving tables need more than one dessert, especially when you're hosting children, grandparents, and relatives with very different tastes. That's where Buttercooky Bakery & Café becomes appealing. Established in 1962, Buttercooky has grown into a familiar Long Island bakery name with Nassau County locations in Floral Park and Manhasset. The bakery publishes a dedicated pies menu and offers an extensive selection of cakes, pastries, cheesecakes, cookies, and other desserts. Earlier local Thanksgiving guides have highlighted its apple crumb, pumpkin, pecan, and fruit pies. However, the full 2026 Thanksgiving assortment and holiday pricing should be confirmed directly with your chosen location. You could pick up one traditional pie and round out the dessert table with assorted pastries or a cheesecake. That flexibility makes Buttercooky useful for larger gatherings where one or two pies might not be enough.

   Classic pies & pastriesCrowd varietyLong Island institutionTwo Nassau locations

   Why go: Pair classic holiday pies with high-end pastries, cheesecakes, and cookies to please every guest

   217 Jericho Turnpike, Floral Park, NY 11001 (also: 140 Plandome Rd, Manhasset) (516) 354-3831 Directions

   Locations in Floral Park ((516) 354-3831) and Manhasset ((516) 627-1600). Confirm 2026 holiday pie assortment and advance order cutoffs directly.

5. 5

   The French Workshop — Garden City

   Best for elegant pies and French-style tarts. If you're looking for a dessert that looks a little more polished than the standard grocery-store pie, The French Workshop is worth considering. This bakery has a wide selection of French-inspired pastries, desserts, and family-size creations. Its published pie and tart menu includes several excellent Thanksgiving candidates. The pecan pie uses a sablé-style crust with caramelized pecan filling. There's also a crumble apple pie made with homemade apple filling and a crispy butter crumble. For something richer, the menu includes a chocolate pie finished with chocolate shavings. Other desserts worth considering include apple tart, apricot tart, chocolate tart, mixed fruit tart, and lemon tart. Family-size options are available for several desserts, with the bakery generally describing these as serving approximately 10–12 people. The apple crumble and pecan pie would be natural Thanksgiving choices. A chocolate tart could be a welcome alternative for guests who aren't especially interested in fruit or pumpkin.

   Sablé-crust pecan pieCrumble apple pieFrench fruit tartsChocolate pie

   Why go: Refined, beautiful desserts with buttery sablé crusts and French-pastry craftsmanship

   191 Seventh Street, Garden City, NY 11530 (516) 248-6800 Directions

   Family-size options serve 10–12. Nassau locations include Garden City, Plainview, and Wantagh. Confirm holiday preorders with your preferred store.

6. 6

   Whistle Stop Desserts — Oceanside

   Best for cream pies, cheesecake, and old-fashioned bakery desserts. Whistle Stop Desserts has been serving Oceanside customers for decades, building a following for cheesecake, cakes, and traditional desserts. It's a neighborhood bakery rather than a large specialty supermarket, and its appeal lies in the range of desserts coming out of its kitchen. Published menus and customer reports mention coconut custard, pecan, chocolate pecan, key lime, fruit pies, and cream pies. The bakery is also known for its cheesecakes, including apple crumb and other specialty varieties. For Thanksgiving, a coconut custard or pecan pie could make a good addition to the usual pumpkin and apple lineup. A cheesecake is another option worth discussing when you place your order, particularly if you're hosting guests who prefer a creamier dessert.

   Coconut custardChocolate pecan pieSpecialty cheesecakesNeighborhood favorite

   Why go: Beloved Oceanside staple for rich cream pies, chocolate pecan, and apple crumb cheesecakes

   3424 Lawson Boulevard, Oceanside, NY 11572 (516) 536-8526 Directions

   Call Whistle Stop directly to confirm 2026 Thanksgiving ordering deadlines, holiday varieties, and pickup hours.

7. 7

   Dortoni Bakery — Levittown and East Norwich

   Best for combining Thanksgiving pies with classic Italian bakery desserts. Dortoni has been part of Long Island's bakery scene since 1976, with Nassau County locations in Levittown and East Norwich. The bakery specializes in celebration cakes, Italian pastries, European-style desserts, and traditional baked goods. Earlier Thanksgiving coverage has featured its pumpkin, coconut custard, mince, and berry pies, although the current year's selection should be confirmed directly. Dortoni is especially worth considering if your family likes a mix of Thanksgiving traditions and Italian desserts. You might serve pumpkin or pecan pie alongside cannoli, cookies, or a dessert assortment. The bakery maintains a dedicated Thanksgiving menu page, which currently advertises Thanksgiving Day hours of 8 a.m.–3 p.m. Confirm that schedule for November 26, 2026, along with the available pies and any preorder requirements.

   Holiday pies & cannoliItalian bakery classicsThanksgiving Day hoursTwo Nassau locations

   Why go: Blend American Thanksgiving pies with Italian celebration cakes, cannoli, and pignoli cookies

   3264 Hempstead Turnpike, Levittown, NY 11756 (also: 6247 Northern Blvd, East Norwich) (516) 796-3033 Directions

   Locations in Levittown ((516) 796-3033) and East Norwich ((516) 624-8900). Advertises Thanksgiving Day morning pickup hours; confirm 2026 details.

8. 8

   Sapienza Bake Shop — Elmont

   Best for completing the Thanksgiving dessert table with Italian pastries and bakery classics. Sapienza Bake Shop has a long family baking history, with the Elmont location producing traditional Italian cookies, pastries, and specialty cakes. The bakery's official website emphasizes its on-premises preparation and recipes developed over generations. It's a useful option for families who want Italian desserts alongside their Thanksgiving pies. Past local holiday guides have mentioned apple crumb and blueberry pies at Sapienza, but those varieties have not been confirmed for Thanksgiving 2026. If you're considering Sapienza for pie, call first to ask about the available holiday flavors, sizes, pricing, and pickup schedule. Even if you've already ordered your pumpkin and apple pies elsewhere, a box of Italian cookies or cannoli can provide a nice variety for dessert.

   Generations-old recipesItalian cookies & cannoliHoliday pastry traysOn-premises baking

   Why go: Authentic Italian cookie trays and pastries to round out the dessert table alongside holiday pies

   1376 Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont, NY 11003 (516) 352-5232 Directions

   Call ahead to confirm 2026 holiday pie availability, sizes, and pickup schedule.